Beyond “Performative Wellness” Programs How to Proactively Build an Enduring Culture of Mental Health in the Workplace

By Published On: June 25, 2025

For years, promoting “well-being” at work has simply meant that HR checked a box by providing a generic, pre-packaged mental health wellness program. But we’ve all felt the disconnect—the burnout from masking our struggles, the quiet weight of navigating grief or anxiety while pretending everything is fine—issues not typically addressed by free yoga sessions or a generic EAP hotline. While these items are nice to have, they are often just band-aids on a larger systemic issue if the underlying company culture is one of fear or stigma. What’s far more impactful is investing in the everyday interactions your employees have with each other and with their managers.

The Foundation: Psychological Safety Is Non-Negotiable

The first step is to train your company’s leaders to create and maintain psychological safety in the workplace. This isn’t just a “soft skill”; it’s a core leadership competency for driving innovation and performance in your workforce.

In The Fearless Organization, author Amy C. Edmondson defines psychological safety as “a belief that one will not be punished or humiliated for speaking up with ideas, questions, concerns, or mistakes.” It isn’t about being “nice”; it’s about making candor and learning possible.

Build a Framework That Supports Mental Health

Protect schedules and normalize rest. This begins by creating policies that protect an employee’s most valuable resource: their time.

  • Encourage company leadership to implement mental health days and urge employees to use them.
  • Encourage managers to establish “blackout dates” during which entire teams enjoy group activities that enable them to bond and recharge.
  • Urge leadership at every level to model a healthy work-life balance.

“Fostering employee mental health is not something that can be outsourced; it’s a business imperative and should be addressed as such.”

Provide Accessible and Destigmatized Support Systems

Consider providing therapy or mental health coaching through a third-party mental health provider, which often lowers barriers to access.

  • Review your benefits and provide substantial bereavement leave, training managers on how to compassionately encourage this time off.
  • Establish an ongoing, flexible wellness benefit (such as a stipend) that empowers employees to choose what makes them feel most healthy and re-energized, whether it’s a gym membership, a meditation app, or a massage.

Empower Managers as First Responders (Not Therapists)

  • Equip your leaders to be the first line of support. This involves training managers how to spot behavioral changes in their team members, not just performance decline, so they can initiate supportive conversations early.
  • Demystify the process for providing employees accommodations and leaves of absence so managers can confidently guide employees needing support for their mental health.
  • Introduce a framework for compassionate, direct conversations. Kim Scott’s book Radical Candor teaches leaders how to “care personally” while they “challenge directly,” fostering trust and preventing issues from festering.

The Long Game

Simply put, employees cannot feel safe enough to be vulnerable or seek help in an environment where they don’t feel that they belong. This means HR should do the ongoing work to build a foundation of inclusion and offer peer support opportunities such as employee resource groups (ERGs) or affinity groups.

The data backs this up. In a study published by the Harvard Business Review, a high sense of belonging was linked not only to increased job performance and reduced turnover, but also to a staggering 75% reduction in sick days.

Well-being Is Your Greatest Asset

As an HR leader, your role is to bring out the best in your workforce while balancing the needs of the business. As you implement new mental health programs, it’s essential to track key performance indicators to demonstrate their value to leadership. Regularly assess the effectiveness of these interventions, checking their ROI against metrics such as retention, engagement, and productivity growth across the company.

Building a psychologically healthy workplace isn’t about completely eliminating stress; it’s about building resilience and creating a community where people are recognized as whole, complex human beings. When you invest in your workers’ well-being, they don’t just stay—they engage, innovate, and thrive. That’s not just healthy culture; it’s the future of good business.

The information contained in this site is provided for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject matter.

editor's pick

Advice in Your Inbox

Join our newsletter for free bi-monthly toolkits and downloads on how to hire, support, and retain your best talent.

By submitting you agree to receive occasional emails and acknowledge our Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time.