Is Your Leadership Story Boring?

Rob Sullivan is an international speaker, corporate trainer, and coach whose passion is helping people improve their presence, energy, listening, and communication. Rob contributes regularly to HRinsidr. Follow along for ongoing insights on leadership presence, communication, and professional development.

Leaders are told to communicate vision. To inspire. To align their teams around a compelling narrative. And yet, when asked to describe themselves — in a town hall, a board meeting, a new-leader introduction — most leaders reach for the same tired language.

“A proven leader with a track record of strategic thinking, team development, and operational excellence.”

That says nothing. No one will remember it. And no one will tell a colleague, “You have to meet her — she has a proven track record.”

Storytelling is not just a skill for job seekers. It is a core leadership competency. How you tell your story in town halls, executive introductions, board presentations, team meetings, and one-on-ones will directly shape how your leadership is perceived and remembered.

The most powerful leadership stories are not about titles or responsibilities. They are about the gap between before and after — the situation as it was, and how it changed because you were there.

Ask yourself these questions about your most important professional experiences:

• What problem existed before you arrived or got involved?
• How long had it been a problem, and who was affected by it?
• What was the cost of not solving it?
• What, specifically, did you do — and how did you get involved?
• Did you take initiative, or were you asked? Either answer tells a story.
• What resources, decisions, or risks were required?
• What was the outcome, and were there any surprising results?

Now: when was the last time you shared any of this in a room that mattered?

I worked with an executive — call him Eric — whose résumé described him as an “innovative problem solver.” He had spent years saying it. He had never once demonstrated it in a conversation.

When I pushed, the real story came out. Eric had been part of a major acquisition integration where outside consultants from one of the top four consulting firms concluded that two data centers couldn’t be merged. On his own time, Eric networked internationally to find someone who had solved an analogous problem. Then he built the solution himself. Within weeks, the “impossible” integration was done.

Eric’s story had never appeared in a presentation. It wasn’t mentioned in his performance review. It was never celebrated as a milestone in the company’s ongoing M&A integrations. Eric genuinely didn’t think it was worth mentioning.

That is the leadership storytelling gap. And it is extraordinarily common at senior levels, where the most capable people are often the least likely to tell you why.

You want people to walk away from an interaction thinking:

“I remember her. She’s the one who ________.”

Fill in that blank with a specific, true, memorable story. Your team will follow someone they can remember for the right reasons. Your peers will advocate for someone whose impact they can articulate. Your organization will trust a leader who can make the abstract concrete.

Ditch the track record language. Tell the story instead.

—

The information contained in this site is provided for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject matter.